Scrap or resell: melt value, refiner payouts and when a piece is worth more as jewellery
Short answer: compare two numbers for each piece: what the refiner will actually pay you for it, and what it can realistically sell for as jewellery, minus the time and cost of selling it. Send it to scrap when the first is higher or close, and keep it for sale when the piece is clearly worth more than its metal.
Melt value
The melt value is the fine gold weight times the reference price of the day. Example: 10 g of 14k gold (585 fineness) holds 10 × 585 ÷ 1,000 = 5.85 g of fine gold. At 100 per gram of fine gold, in your currency, that is 5.85 × 100 = 585. The full method is in gold value by weight and karat.
What the refiner pays
A refiner does not pay the full melt value. The payout depends on their terms: a share of the metal value, assay and processing fees, a minimum lot and the time until payment. Ask each refiner for written terms and compare what you would receive for the same lot.
- Remove stones and non-gold parts first.
- Weigh and record each lot before it leaves, and compare with the refiner's assay.
When a piece is worth more as jewellery
- Brand or maker. A known maker can be worth more than the gold. See branded jewellery.
- Stones. Good stones are lost value in a melt. See stones and diamonds in pawned jewellery.
- Condition and style. An undamaged, wearable piece in a style that sells in your shop can fetch more than its metal.
When scrap is the better choice
Broken chains, single earrings, worn rings and pieces with old repairs often sell for little more than their metal. Holding them costs space and time.
Decide with your own numbers
Record what scrapped lots paid, what resold pieces sold for and how long they took. Over time you will see which pieces belong in which pile.
How PawnMeter helps
PawnMeter calculates the metal value from the official reference price of the day, so the melt figure is the same at every counter. Set it against the refiner's written terms and the resale price to make the decision.
PawnMeter: Type the item. PawnMeter shows the resale price and a suggested loan, calculated only from what comparable items really sold for. When there is not enough data, it says so instead of guessing.
Become a pilot partner